Skip to main content

O Say What is Truth Part 2

Note: This is part two in a three part analysis. Part one can be found here

Second Assumption

The pathways to understanding Truth are legion. This posit would entail epistemological considerations that I'm not interested in following here, but anyone curious could start here for an overview of the philosophy. Rather, I'm interested in pursuing broader swaths of understanding and knowledge, recognizing that a lot of the road has been paved by philosophers and theologians, but focusing more on my own process of thinking.

To begin, I think there's something to be said about prima facie impulses about basic sensory data. The sun is hot, we can feel it and see it, and those physical stimuli come from a cause which we can point to and agree with. Intersubjective agreement may be necessary on one level, but once there, we're discussing common knowledge, verified through the senses. This kind of truth can be considered a rudimentary Truth--human senses are triggered via external processes that allow humans a subjective experience of an objective world. 

And that's a secondary, important contingent to how I conceive of Truth: It operates independently of observation. The sun shone on uninhabited parts of the planet before, it does now, and it will later. Things existed before humans were around to perceive it--a literal reading of the Bible supports that claim. (Whether the locus of continued existence resides in Deity is beside the point; humans are not the road of reality, but instead vehicles on the highway.) 

While there are appeals to different sorts of ways of knowing--authority, tradition, science, emotion--these aren't the areas that I'm most interested in exploring. Instead, I want to tighten what I mean by my second assumption, and that's by returning to Brigham Young's quote:
“Mormonism,” so-called, embraces every principle pertaining to life and salvation, for time and eternity. No matter who has it. If the infidel has got truth it belongs to “Mormonism.” 
The implication of this quote is wide, as it means that Taoism is part of Mormonism, and swaths of atheism fit into my religion, and there is common ground that Satanists and and Saints could agree upon. This spectrum runs from vague, universal assertions to the doctrinally specific: A secular humanist could make a claim about human worth, and I could condone that. A Baptist could insist that adult baptism is necessary, and I would nod my head in agreement. A Jew could assert that God wishes for Sabbath-day observance, and I would be with her in weekly adoration.

Now, it doesn't take much imagination to see the limits of where this Venn Diagram breaks down, as there are areas that don't overlap: Nomenclature notwithstanding, I will side with other Christians and disagree with a Muslim about Jesus' role in God's plan. I can agree with the precept that free will is a part of the human experience, as some atheists do, but I wouldn't back up their claims of no God at all. That there are differences isn't what matters here; it's what's the same.

This is part of what draws me to Milton: His proto-Mormon understanding of God's feelings, behaviors, and choices have a lot of parallels to the scriptures I adhere to. For some people, the Swedish theologian Swedenborg also taps into lines that parallel and overlap Mormonism. The echoes of human worth and virtue that reverberate through the classics have inspired Christian writers from before Dante and long after I will draw my last breath.

"Discovering" these Truths that map onto each other, at whatever scale, is part of the inherent flexibility and ubiquity of Truth. This is why I feel that the pathways to understanding Truth are manifold--there are so many different ways of looking at the world, considering its past, pondering its future, and believing in its origin. While some are incompatible (purpose of life for a Norseman is different than for a Muslim as it is for a Mormon), even the impulse to understand Truth is mirrored in each tradition. If there's a Truth, then it will manifest itself in myriad ways--and not one of them is complete. Even Mormonism admits to being incomplete, as the ninth Article of Faith observes:
We believe all that God has revealed, all that He does now reveal, and we believe that He will yet reveal many great and important things pertaining to the Kingdom of God.
It's my belief that additional revelations do and continue to come from sources outside of Mormonism.

And that leads to my third assumption.

Popular posts from this blog

Dark Necessities

The second of my "music video essays", I'm exploring the single from Red Hot Chili Peppers' newest album, The Getaway , "Dark Necessities". As I did before, I'm posting the video and the lyrics here on the essay, and encourage you to watch and read along. In the case of the Peppers, it's always a good idea to have the lyrics handy, as the lead singer, Anthony Kiedis, has a tendency of mumbling and/or pronouncing words uniquely to create a particular effect--or he's super high, either possibility is there.  The Set Up Here's the video: And here are the lyrics : Coming out to the light of day We got many moons than a deeper place So I keep an eye on the shadow's smile To see what it has to say You and I both know Everything must go away Ah, what do you say? Spinning off, head is on my heart It's like a bit of light and a touch of dark You got sneak attacked from the zodiac But I see your eyes spark Keep the breeze and go Blow...

Rage Against the Video Game Machine?

NOTE: If you haven't read the ' Foregrounding ' blog post or the one entitled ' Rough Draft ', please do that first. They're both short, but they matter a lot for what you're about to read. Okay. Done. Enjoy. Zach de la Rocha: "On truth devoured/Silent play in the shadow of power/A spectacle monopolized/The cameras eyes on choice disguised." Rage Against the Machine's single "Guerilla Radio" from their Battle of Los Angeles album is a reaction against the political circus and faux-choice presentations during the 2000 elections. The quote is not in full context (it is much more political than theoretical) here, but it provides a powerful starting block. A little bit of re-punctuation will help to clarify the thrust: "On truth devoured, silent play in the shadow of power [is] a spectacle [that] monopolized the cameras' eyes-on choice disguised." Line by line, we see parallels between how video games are perceived outside o...

Never Been Worse

A few miles from my house, a mentally ill man forced an evacuation of an elementary school , claiming he had a truck full of explosives. The school evacuated with no casualties or problems and, as of this writing, the perpetrator was in custody. In New York over the weekend, a bomb was set off in Chelsea, leading to a manhunt that has already been resolved . Stabbings in Minnesota . Yet another cop-related shooting, this time in Oklahoma . This is the news of the last twenty-four hours. It can be hard at times like this to declare, unequivocally (also with hyperbole), that this it has never been worse in this country. As a history teacher, it's hard not to want to raise my hand, clear my throat, and say, albeit timidly, "That's not true." The hard part isn't looking into the history books for the evidence. It's feeling as though the data aren't skewed. Anyone can look up the information. In the last two decades alone,  FBI statistics  show a st...